Clean Steel Standards and Optimizing Gear Design

Reduce the risk of nonmetallic inclusion-induced failures

Gears serve as essential mechanisms in a wide range of mechanical equipment, helping to transmit torque, adjust rotational speeds, transfer power, distribute load and more. Used in necessary applications such as automobiles, energy systems, aerospace and industrial equipment, gears must be able to operate for long periods without maintenance. While gears can be made from a diverse assortment of materials, carbon and alloy steel offer superior benefits in terms of strength, durability and cost efficiency. As a remarkably recyclable material, steel may also be a preferable choice for environmentally conscious manufacturers.

While steel is a common choice for gear design, the numerous available options in grades, strengths and treatments can be daunting. The most important first step for gear manufacturers when investigating steel grades and applications is selecting a steel supplier with the capability to produce clean steel and provide technical support. This is crucial because having clean steel helps in consistently achieving the desired chemical, mechanical and physical properties for the final product.

Clean Steel—A Key Component in Modern GearDesign

Innovations in steel manufacturing have greatly improved the quality of steel that can be used for gears. These innovations have largely focused on the development of advanced “clean steel” practices. This phrase refers to steel that lacks detrimental nonmetallic inclusions, making it more durable. If not properly removed, certain nonmetallic inclusions can lead to fractures in gears, risking the chance of a recall and safety hazards.

To consistently develop components that balance reliability, performance and sustainability for high-stress applications, gear manufacturers need access to supremely clean steel. While no reputable steel supplier will aim to create a product riddled with imperfections, there are ways to identify suppliers that are more conscientious of their product’s cleanliness. For example, a detail-oriented supplier with precise processes focused on preventing the formation of these detrimental inclusions, as well as a continual investment in monitoring equipment and lab testing capabilities, will be better equipped to deliver the highest-quality steels for gear applications compared to those that don’t devote time, effort and resources to such practices.

Ensuring Clean Steel Quality: A Guide for Gear Manufacturers

While it is one thing for a supplier to say that they are focused on providing clean steel, a gear manufacturer that recognizes the correct procedures will be well prepared to identify and select the right supplier to help meet their high-performance and durability standards.

Argon rinsing at the ladle refining station promotes flotation of nonmetallic inclusions.

Throughout the various phases of steel manufacturing, there are key processes and procedures within each phase that can help showcase a supplier’s dedication to clean steel. During the melting phase, the type of furnace used can be the first indicator. While blast furnace sourced steels were once considered the cleanest steel, advanced process controls paired with electric arc furnaces (EAFs) are now producing clean steel while also operating more sustainably. Using electrical currents to melt recycled steel, EAFs help reduce CO2 emissions by 75 percent compared to the alternatives in the market. Opting to use steel made from recycled materials at an EAF mill can not only mean a cleaner end product but can help gear manufacturers see a reduction in their carbon footprint.

Beyond the melting phase, gear manufacturers should seek additional benchmarks in their steel partner’s processes, such as maintaining full slag coverage to mitigate atmospheric exposure. Synthetic slag is also essential for ensuring steel cleanliness, performing several critical functions. Besides simply collecting nonmetallic inclusions, synthetic slag also helps prevent atmospheric reoxidation, protects insulating refractories, and insulates electrode arcing.

During the remaining processing, argon rinsing at the ladle refining station and subjecting the liquid steel to pressure between 170 Torr to 1 Torr at the vacuum degasser are crucial practices for producing clean steel by promoting the removal of nonmetallic inclusions. Argon rinsing accelerates the flotation of nonmetallic inclusions to the surface of the ladle, while vacuum degassing reduces unwanted dissolved gases and prevents the reintroduction of oxygen during stirring.

A reputable clean steel supplier will maintain stringent measures through the teeming and casting phase. This includes using specialized refractory equipment, such as low-moisture tundish refractories, to limit oxygen introduction from water. Anticlogging techniques may also be used for preventing nonmetallic buildup, minimizing the risk of contamination in molten steel.

Despite how meticulous some of these processes can be, the commitment to performing and enhancing these measures helps demonstrate a supplier’s dedication to delivering clean, high-quality components for the gear industry. With this background, gear manufacturers can evaluate each supplier’s methodologies and distinguish between a reliable supplier and one that may fail to meet their standards.

Why Clean Steel Matters

For special bar quality (SBQ) forgers and gear manufacturers, using clean steel can significantly reduce the risk of nonmetallic inclusion-induced failures, thus minimizing the need for over-engineering parts in terms of size, weight and cost. Clean steel contributes to reducing the overall weight of machinery, which in turn decreases energy consumption. This is particularly beneficial in automotive and aerospace applications, where efficiency is crucial. Additionally, clean steel offers superior mechanical properties, enhancing the durability, performance and lifespan of high-precision applications.

A reputable clean steel supplier will maintain stringent measures through the teeming and casting phase.

Choosing the right steel partner is essential. A dependable partner offers full metallurgical support through close collaboration, aligning their expertise with the gear manufacturer’s goals. To find a reliable steel partner, prioritize those committed to continuous improvement and collaboration. Partnering with suppliers dedicated to developing cleaner, higher-quality steel variants will enable SBQ forgers and gear manufacturers to produce high-performance products while contributing to a greener, more sustainable future.

chartersteel.com